August 19th, 2008 - Rise Records
Alright, so this is really late. Like, really late. But that's irrelevant.
So anyways, this is Dance Gavin Dance's last record with original vocalist Jon Mess and bassist Eric Lodge. Following the loss of Jonny Craig and the subsequent apprehension of Kurt Travis to fill his shoes, the band subtly changed their style, toning down the disorder and sporadic song structure, rolling back the grittiness, and throwing the ambience on overdrive. That's not to say that this is a completely new band, but while they retain a lot of what made them unique to the scene before, the band--in no small part thanks to the versatility of Travis--have refined their sound into a tighter, more cohesive package.
Compared to the previous two releases, this record is slightly less chaotic in terms of song structure, with each part of each song seeming to have more purpose with regard to its position amongst the other verses, choruses, and bridges. The production seems to reflect this as well, as each of the individual instrument tracks seem to pop more than before. Travis' vocals also shine as he demonstrates his vocal range and versatility, often in the form of harmonized parts. Mess' vocals, however, seem to have lost their edge. It seems as though with each record, his vocals have become less gutteral and raspy, culminating with this record's hoarse yells (perhaps due to his duo of diseases- acid reflux and Lyme's disease). The change is welcomed though, as this record would not have mixed well with the screams from
Whatever I Say Is Royal Ocean. The band also features guest vocalists, a noteworthy addition. Among the guests (alright, there are only three) are Chino Moreno from Deftones (featured on
Caviar) and Matt Geise of Lower Definition (
Rock Solid). The guests, though fantastic in their own endeavors, are underutilised on this record. Underutilised, except, of course, for Nic Newsham. Newsham (formerly of Gatsbys American Dream), no stranger to guest vocals, wrote and performed on
Uneasy Hearts Weigh The Most, perhaps the best track on the record. It's a fantastic cut that showcases the band's somewhat newfound ability to shift styles while retaining a common musical theme, and it's funny as hell without being over-the-top, like some of the other lyrics.
With all this talk of change, it might be safe to assume that this is a whole new band entirely. Fortunately, this isn't the case, as fans of the old records will find familiarity in many a place on this record. The lyrics are similarly styled, specifically Mess' portions, where he shovels out lyric after lyric with little to no apparent cohesion, but somehow it works. Will Swan (lead guitars) still pumps out the insane lead riffs, and the drumming from Matt Mingus is stil top-notch. The musicianship overall is still crisp and tight, and the final product is still notably Dance Gavin Dance. This is one of the best of '08 from a band that can roll with change and still put out top-notch records time and time again.
Verdict: A